Byproducts and Co-Products: Which Critical Minerals Depend on Other Metals

Facts checked against sources on . How we check facts.

More than half of the minerals on the U.S. critical minerals list are produced as byproducts or co-products of other metals. The 2025 Federal Register notice marks 35 of the 60 minerals that way, including all 15 rare earth elements listed individually, four of the five platinum group metals, and gallium, germanium, indium, tellurium, rhenium and cobalt. Zinc, nickel and copper are the most common host metals, which means supply of these minerals cannot be expanded without raising output of the host.

35 of 60

minerals on the 2025 U.S. list are produced as byproducts or co-products (synthetic graphite counted)

Source: Federal Register, 7 November 2025

15 of 15

individually listed rare earth elements are byproducts or co-products of other rare earths, iron ore or heavy mineral sands

Source: Federal Register, 7 November 2025

7

listed minerals come from zinc: arsenic, bismuth, gallium, germanium, indium, silver and tellurium

Source: Federal Register, 7 November 2025

0

tellurium refined in the United States; copper telluride from two copper refineries is exported for processing

Source: USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026

Which host metals produce which critical minerals?

The table inverts the Federal Register notice's byproduct table so that each host metal shows the listed minerals recovered from it. The notice adds that a number of the byproducts are increasingly recovered as co-products, which contribute significant value to mining or processing.

Listed critical minerals by host commodity
Host commodityListed minerals recovered from itWhat USGS adds
ZincArsenic, bismuth, gallium, germanium, indium, silver, telluriumGallium is recovered predominantly from bauxite and also from zinc ores; no primary gallium has been recovered in the U.S. since 1987. Indium was not recovered from ores in the U.S. in 2025.
NickelCobalt, iridium, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, scandium, telluriumThe Eagle Mine in Michigan produced cobalt-bearing nickel concentrate that was exported for processing.
CopperArsenic, bismuth, cobalt, rhenium, silver, telluriumTellurium and selenium accumulate in copper anode slimes; the U.S. produced copper telluride at two refineries, in Texas and Utah.
LeadAntimony, arsenic, bismuth, silver, telluriumMost secondary antimony is recovered at secondary lead smelters.
PlatinumIridium, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, telluriumSmall quantities of PGMs are also recovered in Michigan as byproducts of copper-nickel mining and exported for refining.
GoldAntimony, arsenic, silverSilver was produced at 4 U.S. silver mines and as a byproduct or coproduct from 31 base- and precious-metal operations.
MolybdenumBismuth, rheniumU.S. rhenium comes from roasting molybdenum concentrates from porphyry copper-molybdenum deposits in Arizona and Montana.
Zirconium, titanium and tinHafnium and scandium (from zirconium); scandium and zirconium (from titanium); bismuth and zirconium (from tin)Zircon is a coproduct of heavy-mineral sands mining in Florida and Georgia.
Other rare earths, iron ore and heavy mineral sandsAll 15 individually listed rare earthsSee the rare earth pages for supply by element.
Other hostsVanadium (steel slag from vanadiferous iron ore, spent catalysts); germanium (coal fly ash); gallium (bauxite); rubidium (cesium, lithium)

Sources: Federal Register, Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals for the host commodities; USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 chapters on tellurium, gallium, indium, nickel, rhenium, antimony, PGMs, silver and zirconium. Counts are our arithmetic on the notice's table.

Why does byproduct status limit supply?

A byproduct is recovered from material the host operation already mines and processes, so its output follows the host rather than demand for the byproduct. USGS says the supply of tellurium is directly affected by the supply of the materials it comes from, primarily copper, and that U.S. recovery of copper telluride fell in 2025 with lower copper cathode output. The same logic applies to rhenium and molybdenum, and to gallium and germanium, where Chinese zinc and bauxite processing dominates recovery. Several of these metals are now recovered as co-products where their value justifies investment; examples are the new gallium and germanium projects in Canada and Australia described on the chip metals page.

Why are the minerals that are not byproducts different?

The 25 listed minerals without byproduct status are mined for their own sake: lithium, nickel, copper, aluminum, tungsten, niobium, tantalum, manganese, chromium, potash, phosphate, uranium and others. Their output can respond directly to price, subject to the long lead times covered on the exploration and resources page. The byproduct risk page shows how criticality frameworks treat the difference.

Frequently asked questions

Which critical minerals are byproducts?

The 2025 U.S. critical minerals list marks 35 of its 60 minerals as byproducts or co-products, including antimony, arsenic, bismuth, cobalt, gallium, germanium, hafnium, indium, rhenium, scandium, silver, tellurium, vanadium, zirconium, all 15 individually listed rare earths and four platinum group metals. Natural graphite is not a byproduct, but synthetic graphite is.

What metals are gallium, germanium and indium byproducts of?

Gallium comes from bauxite and zinc, germanium from zinc and coal fly ash, and indium from zinc, according to the Federal Register notice. USGS adds that gallium is recovered predominantly from bauxite processing.

Why is tellurium supply tied to copper?

Tellurium is recovered from the anode slimes left by electrolytic copper refining, so more tellurium needs more copper refined. USGS says its supply is directly affected by copper supply.

Can byproduct supply be scaled up quickly?

Not independently of the host metal. Output follows the host mine or smelter, unless a new recovery plant is added to existing operations, as in recent gallium and germanium projects.

Sources

Read on October 13, 2026. Figures on this page come from these documents; where a number is an estimate, the source says so.

  1. Federal Register: Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals (7 November 2025). Byproduct and host-commodity table read in full from the Federal Register text file
  2. USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: tellurium, gallium, indium, rhenium, nickel, antimony, silver, platinum-group metals, zirconium and hafnium. Chapters read as PDFs; each is linked under the table

Stay Informed on Critical Minerals

Get weekly updates on supply chains, policy developments, and market moves delivered straight to your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.